Federal Grand Jury Banner


 

 

    Site Map   Links Home

Search
FAQ's about Grand Juries Federal Grand Jury Info Multimedia Overview
Feedback, Comments, & Stories State Grand Jury Info Grand Juries in the News

Note: The comments and questions on this page came from people who visited this website. Please feel free to send your comments and questions to Professor Brenner (brenner@udayton.edu). She will respond privately, and may ask permission to post your message on this page. No one's e-mail will be used without first obtaining their permission, and names and e-mail addresses are removed before a comment is posted. Starting in 2002, the responses posted to the site indicate which of us replied: The initials SWB mean Professor Brenner wrote the response; the initials LES mean Professor Shaw wrote the response. We are also putting the year down, to indicate when the response was posted. If no initials appear, Professor Brenner wrote the response.

What rights do I have when questioned by the FBI? Can I take the Fifth? 

I know you have the "right to remain silent" upon arrest, but what sort of rights apply when for instance, the FBI questions an individual under investigation? Can you plead the 5th prior to an arrest?

Response: If you're not in custody (i.e., if a reasonable person in your situation would believe he/she is free to leave without being detained by the agents), you're not entitled to Miranda, which means you don't have the rights to silence or counsel. However, you can always refuse to answer questions posed by law enforcement officers; that's an outgrowth of your Fifth Amendment rights. So you can simply tell the agents you don't want to talk to them, and walk away. At that point, they will either have to arrest you (which will require that they have probable cause, already, to believe you've committed a crime) or have a prosecutor subpoena you before a grand jury, where you will have to answer unless you can take the 5th as to each question (meaning, you'd have to show answering would implicate you in a crime).

Can such silence bring about obstruction of justice charges?

Response: Silence will not, but if you lie, you can be charged with obstructing justice or lying to an officer (depending on the jurisdiction you're in). And a number of courts have held that pre-arrest silence can be introduced into evidence at trial, as the basis from which the jury can infer guilt (i.e., an innocent person would talk, so silence must establish guilt).

Federal Grand Jury
Home Page

 


E-mail questions, comments, or suggestions regarding this site 

Credits: Susan Brenner, Lori Shaw
Website Research Assistant : Dave Hunter
Copyright 1997 - 2003 All rights reserved
Privacy Policy