A: Discussions of Mary's virginity
eventually came to examine Mary's virginity during three periods: ante
partum (i.e. before the birth of Christ); in partu (i.e. during
the delivery of Christ); and post partum (i.e. after the birth of
Christ). Your question involves what came to be called Mary's virginitas
The best sources of information on Mary's virginity
prior to the birth of Jesus are the Infancy narratives in the Gospels of
Matthew and Luke, usually dated around 80 A.D. There are also several
writings before 350 on both Mary's virginitas in partu and on her
virginitas post partum which expand on the Biblical reflection about
Mary's virginitas ante partum.
The first witnesses are to be found in the Apocrypha
from around 150, especially: the Protogospel of James, the Book
of Sybils, the Ascent of Isaiah, and the Acts of Peter
(see: Corp. Mar. I, 131-158). These apocryphal texts may not be
considered sufficient doctrinal justification for Mary's lifelong virginity.
However, they point out how widespread the conviction about this point was
among early Christians.
There are suggestions that Irenaeus (d. circa 220) and Justin (d. circa 165) may have alluded to Mary's virginitas in partu, but there are no explicit statements by either author. Origen (d. 254) may have been the first to affirm Mary's lifelong virginity (see: PG 14, 320) in commenting on the Protogospel of James (see also Corp. Mar. 265; GCS 38, 42f; PG 13, 1631). Clement of Alexandria (d. ca 215) accepted the Protogospel of James without problem (Strom VII, 16, 93, 7) along with its perspective on Mary as ever-virgin. However, Tertullian (d. circa 200) rejected the apocryphal protogospel and with it Mary's virginitas in partu and her virginitas post partum (see De carne Christi, 23).
Return to Your Questions
This page, maintained by The Marian Library/International Marian Research Institute, Dayton, Ohio 45469-1390, and created by J. C. Tierney , was last modified Monday, 10/20/2008 14:52:19 EDT by Michael P. Duricy . Please send any comments to email@example.com.